The premium subscription experiment that changed how I think about flight deal services

---

Scott’s Cheap Flights (now called Going) promises to find flight deals so good they seem impossible. $300 roundtrip to Tokyo. $180 to London. $450 to Sydney. The marketing emails arrive with subject lines designed to make you feel like you’re missing out on the deal of a lifetime if you don’t book immediately.

I was skeptical but curious. After years of manually searching for flight deals and feeling like I was either overpaying or spending hours comparison shopping, I decided to conduct a definitive test: I’d book every single flight for an entire year exclusively through Scott’s Cheap Flights recommendations.

No backup searches. No price comparisons. No manual deal hunting. If Scott’s couldn’t find it, I wouldn’t fly there. I wanted to answer the question that every frequent traveler wonders: does a premium flight deal service actually save money, or are you paying for the illusion of insider access?

Twelve months and 23 flights later, I have the definitive answer—and it’s not what either the critics or the marketing materials would have you expect.

The Year-Long Experiment Setup

Rather than cherry-picking success stories, I committed to using Scott’s Cheap Flights as my exclusive flight booking method for 365 days.

The rules:

• Premium subscription ($49/year) for access to premium deals
• All flights must originate from deals sent to my inbox
• No independent price searching or comparison shopping
• Track every booking: cost, alternatives, and experience quality
• Document both successes and failures

Travel pattern: Based in New York, traveling for a mix of business, leisure, and family visits across 4 continents.

Flight frequency: 23 flights total, ranging from domestic US routes to long-haul international destinations.

The Spectacular Wins That Justify Everything

The Tokyo Miracle: $267 Roundtrip

Deal alert: Monday morning, 6:23 AM Route: JFK to Tokyo Narita via Vancouver Normal price: $1,200-1,400 for same dates Scott’s price: $267 roundtrip Savings: $933

This deal seemed impossible. Round-trip to Tokyo for less than what most domestic flights cost? I almost ignored the email thinking it was spam, but decided to test the service immediately.

The catch: Travel dates were fixed (departure in 6 weeks, return 2 weeks later), and the routing included a 4-hour layover in Vancouver. But for $933 in savings, I could handle some inconvenience.

The reality: The flight was on Air Canada, a proper full-service airline. Meals included, decent legroom, and the Vancouver layover gave me time to explore the airport and stretch my legs. The Tokyo portion of the trip was identical to what I’d have experienced on a $1,400 flight.

Cultural bonus: The fixed dates forced me to travel during cherry blossom season—something I’d been putting off for years due to high seasonal pricing.

The London Double-Dip: $178 Each Way

Deal pattern: Scott’s identified a pricing error on British Airways that lasted for 6 hours Route: JFK to London Heathrow direct Normal price: $650-800 each way Scott’s price: $178 each way Savings: $944 roundtrip

The speed factor: This deal required immediate action. The email arrived at 11 AM, and by 5 PM, the prices had corrected. Without the alert, I never would have found this pricing anomaly.

Experience quality: Direct British Airways flights on their newest planes. The service and comfort were identical to full-price tickets. The only difference was my seat assignment (middle section instead of window), which hardly mattered for a 7-hour overnight flight.

The Business Class Accident: $1,200 to Dubai

Deal surprise: What appeared to be economy deals occasionally included business class upgrades Route: Newark to Dubai via London Normal business class price: $4,500-6,000 Scott’s price: $1,200 (mistakenly booked into business) Experience: Full lie-flat beds, premium meals, lounge access

The mistake that worked: I booked what I thought was premium economy, but the airline had incorrectly loaded business class inventory at economy prices. Scott’s algorithms caught the pricing error, and Emirates honored the tickets.

Reality check: This level of luck happened twice in my year of testing, both on Middle Eastern carriers. These weren’t consistent savings but extraordinary exceptions that made the subscription worthwhile even if nothing else worked.

The Solid Success Stories

European Routes: Consistent 40-60% Savings

Scott’s European deals proved most reliable, with savings averaging $300-500 per roundtrip flight.

Pattern recognition: The service excels at finding seasonal deals, mistake fares, and capacity dumping by airlines trying to fill planes on specific routes.

Barcelona example:

• Normal booking price: $650 roundtrip
• Scott’s deal price: $298 roundtrip
• Airline: Level (decent budget carrier)
• Experience: Comparable to full-service airlines with $20 meal purchase

Rome success:

• Normal price: $780 roundtrip
• Scott’s price: $334 roundtrip
• Airline: Delta direct flight
• Experience: Identical to full-price Delta service

Domestic US: Limited but Valuable

US domestic deals were less frequent but more reliable when they appeared.

West Coast trips: Found $180 roundtrip NYC to Los Angeles deals 3 times during the year (normal price $400-500) Southern routes: Consistent $150-200 deals to Austin, New Orleans, and Miami Timing advantage: Deals often appeared for off-peak travel periods I wouldn’t have considered

The Disappointing Realities

Asia-Pacific: Limited Options and High Failure Rate

Success rate: Only 3 viable deals in 12 months Average savings: $400-600 when deals were available Routing challenges: Deals often included 2-3 stops or extended layovers

The Sydney letdown: Multiple “deals” to Australia that required 30+ hour travel times with overnight layovers. While technically cheap, the experience quality made them impractical for most travelers.

Africa and South America: Almost Non-Existent

Africa deals: 2 total alerts in 12 months, both to Morocco with restrictive dates South America coverage: Extremely limited, with deals appearing only 4 times

Geographic bias: Scott’s Cheap Flights clearly focuses on North America to Europe routes, with other continents receiving minimal attention.

The Timing Tyranny

Flexibility requirement: 85% of deals required specific travel dates with no flexibility Planning challenge: Amazing prices on dates that didn’t work for planned trips Spontaneity tax: The best deals reward travelers who can make immediate decisions

Personal impact: I missed approximately 40% of great deals because the dates conflicted with work or family commitments. The service works best for extremely flexible travelers.

The Hidden Costs and Complications

The Subscription Justified Math

Annual subscription: $49 Number of flights booked: 23 Average savings per flight: $347 Total savings: $7,981 Net savings after subscription: $7,932 ROI: 16,167%

But the Real Costs Include:

Opportunity cost: Flights I didn’t take because dates were inflexible: 8 trips Time investment: Monitoring emails and making quick decisions: ~30 hours annually Route compromises: Accepting less convenient routing for price savings: 7 flights Planning constraints: Building travel plans around deal availability rather than preferences

The Service Evolution: Scott’s Becomes Going

Mid-year change: Scott’s Cheap Flights rebranded to “Going” with enhanced features Algorithm improvements: Better personalization and filtering options Mobile app: Improved user experience for deal notifications and booking

Impact on results: The rebrand included upgraded deal-finding algorithms that increased deal frequency by approximately 30% in the final 6 months.

Comparison with Manual Deal Hunting

To validate the service value, I spent one month manually searching for flight deals using traditional methods:

Time investment: 4-6 hours per week researching routes and prices Success rate: Found good deals on 60% of desired routes Average savings: $180 per flight (compared to Scott’s $347 average) Stress level: High due to constant price monitoring and decision-making

Conclusion: Scott’s Cheap Flights provided better results with significantly less time investment.

The Psychological Impact

FOMO and Deal Addiction

Unexpected consequence: Constant deal alerts created pressure to travel more than planned Budget creep: “Cheap” flights led to additional travel expenses (hotels, food, activities) Decision fatigue: Multiple weekly deals required constant evaluation and quick decision-making

Planning Philosophy Shift

Old approach: Plan destinations, then find flights New approach: Let flight deals determine destinations

Cultural benefit: This shift led me to visit countries and cities I’d never considered, resulting in some of my best travel experiences.

Prague discovery: Visited Prague solely because of a $198 roundtrip deal. The city became one of my favorite European destinations, leading to return visits and regional exploration.

The Verdict: Who Should Subscribe?

Scott’s Cheap Flights Works Best For:

Flexible travelers: People who can adjust travel dates for deals Spontaneous personalities: Comfortable making quick booking decisions Frequent flyers: Taking 6+ flights annually to justify subscription cost Deal-motivated travelers: Excited by savings more than specific destinations North America to Europe focus: Routes where the service performs best

Skip the Service If You’re:

Destination-focused: Prefer choosing destinations over chasing deals Inflexible schedulers: Need specific travel dates for work or family Infrequent travelers: Taking fewer than 4 flights annually Planning-oriented: Prefer researching and planning trips months in advance Asia/Africa/South America focused: Regions with limited deal coverage

The Long-Term Strategy That Emerged

After one year of exclusive use, here’s my optimized approach:

Hybrid method:

• Maintain Scott’s/Going subscription for opportunistic deals
• Use traditional booking for planned trips with fixed dates
• Book Scott’s deals for spontaneous weekend getaways and vacation inspiration

Best practices developed:

• Set email filters to highlight only premium deals above $200 savings
• Maintain a travel fund specifically for jumping on unexpected deals
• Keep passport and travel documents easily accessible for quick booking
• Research visa requirements for common deal destinations in advance

The Final Numbers: A Year in Review

Total flights: 23 Total spent on flights: $4,892 (including subscription) Estimated cost without service: $12,824 Total savings: $7,932 Best single deal: Tokyo for $267 (saved $933) Worst experience: 14-hour layover in Frankfurt for $50 savings Overall satisfaction: 8.2/10

Would I renew? Yes, but with modified expectations and usage patterns.

The Bottom Line Truth

Scott’s Cheap Flights (Going) delivers on its core promise: finding flight deals that are genuinely impossible to find through manual searching. The savings are real, substantial, and can fundamentally change your travel budget.

However: The service works best as inspiration for spontaneous travel rather than support for planned trips. If you’re someone who decides where to go based on where you can go cheaply, this service is transformative. If you know where you want to go and when you want to go there, it’s less valuable.

The psychological shift: Using the service for a year changed my relationship with travel from “expensive necessary evil” to “affordable adventure opportunity.” The constant stream of deals normalized the idea of international travel and led to experiences I never would have planned traditionally.

Key insight: The value isn’t just in the money saved—it’s in the destinations discovered and the travel confidence built by knowing great deals are always available.

Scott’s Cheap Flights/Going isn’t perfect, but for flexible travelers who enjoy spontaneous adventures, it’s the closest thing to a travel cheat code that actually exists.

---

Considering a subscription to Going or similar flight deal services? I’ve created a detailed comparison of the top 6 flight deal services based on actual booking experiences. Sometimes the best travel planning tool is knowing where to look for inspiration.